BBB to AAA, the CDO trick

After rereading the article below and help from wikipedia, I finally understood how to transform BBB debt into AAA debt, and the whole colateralized debt obligation (CDO) thing that seemed so magical and is supposed to have gotten us in the mess.

The trick is actually quite simple. It says put all your BBB together in a company (SPV or Special Purpose Vehicle) and redistribute payments from the lot to create a sub AAA tranche. The investors in that tranche are holding on to a AAA rated security.

By redistributing the cash flows, you can in fact extract 10% of AAA and leave 90% residue that is worse than the original BBB. Making up numbers here.

Investors awash in leverage, loved to consume the AAA tranche, plus some entities can only buy AAA securities. Bankers loved to make them.

Furthermore I am under the impression from reading this article that they in fact recycled the leftovers from the first CDO process into another CDO. Except at that level you are stretching to find a cash flow that are in fact alive in that cesspool and I guess it is easy to mis-rate these second derivative securities. Apparently rating agencies applied ratings to the various CDO tranches without much understanding of the underlying security.

Comments

Anonymous said…
I almost understand this stuff now, but I still can't see how even 10% of a BBB tranch gets to be rated AAA. This slicing also rakes of outright fraud. Is it that you actually pay off the top 10% first, even if they are all at the same risk of going under.

Forgive me here. I'm Hillary's age with a couple of tech degrees and this stuff is getting interesting.
November 27, 2008 at 10:12:00 PM PST
Anonymous said…
right - you take a BBB mortgage backed security and divide it up. let's say you make a 95% AAA tranche in your new CDO and the rest is BBB. if the risk of default per mortgage is 5%, then this works because if the BBB rating is correct, defaults will only stop 5% of the cash flow, only affecting the lower tranche.
December 2, 2008 at 11:18:00 PM PST
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

$6.66B for BEA: Larry goes Shopping

Oracle has made a $17 per share offer to buy BEA. This putting a somewhat theatrical "number of the beast" valuation on BEA. Yesterday the stock was sitting at $13 and this morning it is at 18 and change representing a 30% jump. Obviously the crazy dude over at BEA is going to put up at least a simulacrum of a fight. Thinking of it, I expect Alfred "I am compensating for..." to put a heartfelt final battle into this, he has probably already super-glued his naked chest to the BEA boardroom table. It is going to get nasty and he will be dragged out kicking and screaming. Alfred will mumble something about not wanting to be Larry's power point bitch, or waxing his boat, or some other non-sense. But Larry is going to make sushi of that board and will feed it to the koi fish he has in his compound and cost more per head than Alfred's car... This one is going to be funny to watch. Pass the popcorn please. First, because of ICahn's shareholder activism, th
Read more

Thug vs Thug: Porsche 1, Hedge Funds: 0

The latest drama is fun. VW became the largest company in the world, in terms of market cap, ahead of EXXON on a little financial market coup d'etat orchestrated by Porsche. Apparently VW stocks was on the way down, I don't know the details but many Hedge Funds (HF) were short the position. Fine. The price goes down. Porsche starts buying the anonymous float (and probably some private too?), but the point is they build a 73% market share without many people noticing. In the US you would need disclosure after 10% or so. Point is, that many HF wake up and realize that their short position is about to lose a lot of money. So what do they do? those idiots? they short cover all together, which means they buy the stock to cover the short. The stock zooms up, by a full multiplier and overtakes EXXON. Porsche makes A KILLING in the process and has robbed the city robbers to the tune of "potentially $30B". Not bad for a days worth of work. PS: hey, psst Porsche! With t
Read more

Quickies #3, protecting IP in OSS

Now enjoying my status as a sage of the industry, which is to say I am older than 20, but alas, not a billionaire, God fuck-it; people are all the time asking me for nuggets of wisdom from my vast experience at the top. Quickies from marcf #3: What IP is there to protect in OSS? B.D asks: "marcf, my open source project is starting to enjoy a measure of success, I am thinking of going professional with it, I am thinking about business models. How much thought should I put in protecting my Intellectual Property?" Answer: B.D. protecting IP in OSS is extremelly important. The only "private" property that exists in OSS are 1- brand 2- URL. Both are obviously related but really you need to protect your brand name, in other words REGISTER your trademarks, use them, declare they are yours and enforce the trademark, meaning protect against infringement. Other products, specifically based on your product should not include your name. Consultancies will be able to say the
Read more